This has bitten me numerous times...
on an auction like (1X)-1Y[GIB]-(p)-?? New suits by me are routinely passed by GIB. How exactly is one supposed to show 6+Z and 14 here?
Page 1 of 1
Advances by an UPH are... non-forcing? How exactly do you force here with a good suit?
#2
Posted 2016-June-28, 15:45
Jump shifts are natural and forcing, but that doesn't solve every problem.
Wayne Somerville
#3
Posted 2016-June-29, 10:16
New suits NF after partner's overcall of a 1 level opening bid is still standard, although a large contingent plays them as forcing. As manu says, a jump advance in a new suit is natural and forcing, but isn't always ideal. This is a bigger concern in Robot tourneys on BBO than in real life, where you often may have a reason to bid with less overall strength than partner might hold. On BBO, you always have the best hand or at least equal HCP.
Does anyone know, does GIB play a new suit as forcing after partner's overcall of a weak 2 bid? This is the standard treatment but I don't recall it coming up in a robot tourney.
Does anyone know, does GIB play a new suit as forcing after partner's overcall of a weak 2 bid? This is the standard treatment but I don't recall it coming up in a robot tourney.
#4
Posted 2016-July-03, 04:27
TylerE, on 2016-June-28, 14:04, said:
This has bitten me numerous times...
on an auction like (1X)-1Y[GIB]-(p)-?? New suits by me are routinely passed by GIB. How exactly is one supposed to show 6+Z and 14 here?
on an auction like (1X)-1Y[GIB]-(p)-?? New suits by me are routinely passed by GIB. How exactly is one supposed to show 6+Z and 14 here?
Now I have edited some styles of Gib hands and played these hands by my basic Gib to show your problem,generally speaking, the behavior of Gibs are better and reasonable.
Hand-1
Result : 5♦E-1
Hand-2
Result : 3ntE+2
Hand-3
Result : 1ntE=
Hand-4
Result : 2♦E=
Hand-5
Result : 2♥W=
Hand-6
Result : 4♠W=
Hand-7
Result : 4♥W=
Hand-8
Result : 4♥W-2
I hope everyone go on discussing.
#5
Posted 2016-July-04, 15:35
Most bidding problems are a lot easier when you have a suit that plays for one loser opposite a void. Most of the time you don't have that luxury.
#6
Posted 2016-July-05, 04:41
Well and good, this is third time to discuss this issue, hping you would afford better Gib CC on it.
Page 1 of 1