navit, on May 27 2007, 05:50 AM, said:
I opened with 1 C .pass . partner responded 1 H. PASS. I HAD 4H.18 HCP, 4C, 3S and 2 D. Someone told me to rebid 3S. Is that correct?
dealer, 18hcp, 3=4=2=4, opps silent, bidding was 1C 1H. Some said rebid 3S.
Maybe you should never take advice from those people again.
2S would be a GF jump-shift, not 3S. 3S would be a splinter with singleton/void spade, 4h, GF.
Better bid is 4H. Simple and to the point. You have a GF hand with 4-card support. No more, no less. Why muddy the waters and make partner guess what to do next? Since partner does not know about your heart support, anything partner bids will not likely be useful information.
"Support with support" KISS.