Trinidad, on 2012-February-17, 06:47, said:
Not for me, but the auction would continue:
1N (2D) P (2S)
P (3C)1 P (3H)2
P (4H)3 Dbl4 P5
1N (2D) P (2S)
P (3C)1 P (3H)2
P (4H)3 Dbl4 P5
gnasher, on 2012-February-17, 12:56, said:
I agree with most of this, but wouldn't 3♥ be FSF?
I actually had thought about that, before I posted. You certainly could play it as FSF, but my gut feeling says that you should play it as natural. I don't play FSF in competition since I have a cue available. In my mind, a hand that would have bid FSF now, should have 'cued' 2NT the round before. This leaves 3♥ as natural: Pick a major partner, any major.
Obviously this is very academic since I haven't played natural overcalls after 1NT for ages. And I could easily be wrong.
Rik